MINUTES OF A MEETING OF PERRANUTHNOE PARISH COUNCIL
Held at St Pirans Hall Goldsithney Monday 19th July 2021,1900 hrs
Councillors present Cllrs S Nicholas (Chair) G. Griffiths, J. Jago, D. Sharp, C Leo & R. Greenwood-Penny.
Visitors Present: Mr Les Allen & Ms Isabel Brumwell
Apologies for absence: Cllr Collins – Working but was hoping to join the meeting at some point. Cornwall Cllr Tara Sherfield Wong (Migraine)
20 Minute public speaking period Ms Isabel Brumwell from Laurece Associates spoke on behalf of her client Mr L Allen in support of PA21/07321
Approval of minutes from meeting held on 21st June 2021
These were proposed, seconded, and carried unanimously.
Planning Applications and Relevant matters
PA21/06321 Mr. L Allen Caravan At Seaview Perranuthnoe
Application for Outline Planning Permission with all matters reserved: Construction of replacement dwelling
Cllr Jago declared an interest in this application and did not take part in discussion or voting.
It was proposed and seconded and carried by 4 votes to 1 abstention that PPC opposes the application for the following reasons
1.Whilst we understand the single storey caravan has been granted a certificate of lawfulness the application site is in open countryside and outside the development boundaries of Perranuthnoe village which have be supported by a relies of consultations over recent years as part of the development of the Perranuthnoe NDP.
2.The granting of a certificate of lawfulness does not imply that a permanent dwelling would be acceptable in open countryside. The siting of new development in this location would be damaging and inappropriate and not in line with the proposals set out in the draft Perranuthnoe NDP which wishes to preserve the agricultural setting of this area
3.The application site is within the Cornwall AONB which is recognised for the character and attractiveness of its landscape. We fully support the objections of Cornwall AONB that development in this location would be detrimental to the AONB and the agricultural setting of this open countryside area
4.The outline application gives little detail about the form of the development proposed and we believe in such a sensitive location a detail application would be appropriate.
PA21/05572 Mr. C. Jose Works to 6 trees subject to a TPO Squirrels Access To Bampfylde Way Perran Downs. This will be a referral for the tree officer to look at. The description of the site is incorrect it is an access track off Bampfylde Way not to it
PA21/05738 Mrs. M. Chapple Front extension and alterations. (Revised scheme of PA12/10879) Location Llamudos Trevean Way Rosudgeon It was proposed, seconded, and carried unanimously that Perranuthnoe Parish Council supports the application. Perranuthnoe Parish Council supports the revised scheme subject to it being in keeping with the neighboring property
PA21/05629 Mr. K Kloubeci Demolition of existing barns and construction of dwelling with non-compliance of condition 2 relating to decision notice PA20/01771 Location Trevean Farmhouse Trevean Farm Trevean Lane Rosudgeon.
It was proposed, seconded, and carried unanimously that Perranuthnoe Parish Council opposes the application. On the grounds that the previous application was a one level bungalow type dwelling. Condition 2 was that it had to be built as per those plans with a number of conditions. This recent application seeks to build a first floor on it and by removing condition 2 this would be permitted. We request all previous conditions be applied
The application site is within the Cornwall AONB which is recognised for the character and attractiveness of its landscape. In view of its prominent position in the AONB development in this location would be detrimental to the AONB and the agricultural setting of this open countryside area
PA21/05977 Mr. &Mrs. J. Stroud Conversion and extension of garage to form self-contained family annexed accommodation Location Luitreth Nanturras Way Goldsithney TR20 9DG It was proposed, seconded, and carried unanimously that Perranuthnoe Parish Council opposes the application This is not an annexe. This appears to be a new build and not an annexe for the family. An annexe should not be self-sufficient it needs to be used in connection with the existing family home and not a separate property.
PA21/06127 Mr. & Mrs. J Marden Replacement rear extension Location 9 Meadow View Goldsithney TR20 9HB It was proposed, seconded, and carried unanimously that Perranuthnoe Parish Council supports the application. Perranuthnoe Parish Council Supports this planning application for a new conservatory within the rear extension,
PA21/05911 Mr. K. Laukkanen & Mrs. Lohikoski
Proposal Listed Building Consent: Replacement of Crittall windows, Installation of replacement modern secondary glazing system (to improve thermal and acoustic performance) Location North Wing John Stackhouse Apartment/Susannas Apartment Acton Castle Trevean Lane It was proposed, seconded, and carried unanimously that Perranuthnoe Parish Council supports the application. Perranuthnoe Parish Council Supports the Replacement of crittal windows on the proviso that the Listed building Officers are in agreement.
PA21/01564 Mr. &Mrs. Beevers Proposal: Detached two storey dwelling Location: Land Rear Of Rose Cottage North Road Goldsithney Cornwall TR20 9JY
It was proposed, seconded, and carried unanimously that Perranuthnoe Parish Council opposes the application. Perranuthnoe Parish Council opposes this application on the following grounds.
1. They feel it is overdevelopment in North Road
2. The proposed dwelling is out of keeping with the area.
3. There is insufficient parking and amenity space
4. It will have significant bearing and overlook the property sited on the boundary of the plot
5. It would result in an established (old) willow tree being cut down.
PA21/05872 Mr. &Mrs. Ridley Proposal Demolition of a stone out-building within owners’ garden, Replacement 2 bed annexe with holiday usage. Location Sycamore House Fore Street Goldsithney TR20 9LQ It was proposed, seconded, and carried unanimously that Perranuthnoe Parish Council opposes the application.
Perranuthnoe Parish Council opposes this application for the following reasons
1. An annexe should not be self-sufficient but linked to the main property.
2. This is a proposal for a separate property for holiday let
3. There is no vehicle access and poor access onto the road
PA21/06158 Mr. J Wright Proposal Amendments to Existing Roof Structure and Associated Works Location 3 The Mews Road From Perran Lane To Church Farm Perranuthnoe
It was proposed, seconded, and carried unanimously that Perranuthnoe Parish Council opposes the application. Perranuthnoe Parish Council strongly objects to this application for the enlargement of this tiny property in the center of Perranuthnoe. On the following grounds:
1) The nature of the original conversion is such that there is very little external amenity land around the dwelling
2) The impact on the neighbouring property will be significant
3) There is objection from neighbouring properties re lack of privacy & light.
4) It is out totally out of keeping with the Perranuthnoe Conservation Area
5) The village is already overrun with visitors and cars additional occupants should be provided with additional car parking.
6) Small scale buildings such as this one should be retained as at present Tally out keeping in the conservation area and will impact on neighbours
PA21/05703 Mr. & Mrs. Polley Proposal First floor extension and new porch Location 25 St Petry Goldsithney TR20 9LA.
It was agreed to defer any decision on this application and to consult with the planning officer.
Mr Allen & Ms Brumwell left the meeting at 19.20
Mr & Mrs D ’Unger joined the meeting at 19.30 and left the meeting at 19.36
Cllr Collins joined the meeting at 19.38
The following planning permissions were noted as being granted.
23.06.2021 PA20/09561 APPROVED Applicant: N/A Location: Gorregan Rosudgeon Penzance Cornwall TR20 9PG Proposal: Demolition of existing dormer bungalow and construction of two dwellings
30.06.2021 PA21/03293 APPROVED Applicant: Mrs. J Lee Location: Ednovean House Ednovean Lane Perranuthnoe Penzance Cornwall Proposal: Conversion and Extension of Outbuilding to Form an Incidental Use to Main Dwelling House
The following planning permissions were noted as being refused
To Note other planning related matters.
30.06.2021 PA21/05324 Decided not to make a TPO (TCA apps) Applicant: Mr. R Hall Location: Lamorna House 8 North Road Goldsithney TR20 9JY Proposal: Application for tree works with a Conservation Area: Raise crown to 5m and remove dead wood from crown on two Ash Trees Parish
PA21/01556/PREAPP Long Cliffs Perranuthnoe Clients Jamie O’Donoghue & Yvonne Yeung – Eldridge Newlyn Architects. Statement from PPC submitted to planning Department on 12th July 2021
APP/D0840/X/21/3277224 Mr. A De Unger The chalet Boat Cove Perranuthnoe Certificate of lawfulness for existing use of the building for holiday purposes. Representations must be received by 16 August 2021
PA20/09172 – Appeal Allowed. Land adj Parc-an-West, Red Lane, Rosudgeon – Ms. V Brooks.
PA19/11124 – Appeal Dismissed. Costs claim against Council – Dismissed.
Land And Buildings East Of The Old Carthouse, Trebarvah Lane, Trebarvah, Perranuthnoe – Mr. and Mrs. Firth.
Mr Peter Linton, (Perranuthnoe) Mr Chris Pascoe (Rosudgeon) and Mrs Shann Rodgers
(Goldsithney) had expressed an interest in becoming a Co-opted Parish Councillor, Clerk to liaise and invite to meeting with current Councillors.
Clerk had met and shared a working lunch in the parish office with the new County Councillor Tara Sherfield Wong.
Cllr Nicholas reported that
1 – Lifeguard service now in place at Perranuthnoe for the summer season
2 – Request for increased visits from the Police to St Pirans Hall because of minor vandalism
3 – Request for Surveyors meeting re the condition of the St Pirans Hall Building
Cllr Nicholas had attended
1) Public Meeting at St Hillary on Friday 16th July for the Nanturras Camp site Planning Application she felt a letter of support should be sent to oppose the PA from PPC
2) Community Network Partnership on the 15th July 2021
3) NDP meeting at the Hall on the morning of Wednesday 7th July and in the afternoon met with Cornwall Cllr Tara Sherfield- Wong, Cllr Greenwood Penny and residents on a site visit at St Petry.
4) St Hilary Parish Council public meeting to discuss the Solar Farm application of St Aubyn’s Estate.
County Cllrs Report
Apologies from County Cllr Sherfield Wong received at 17.30 for non-attendance at tonight’s meeting and not sending a report due to a migraine attack that she had been suffering all
Cllr. Collins – Reported that residents didn’t seem to know what was going on regarding the Old Quarry at Trenow it was alleged that people had been staying in the chalet. This should be reported to enforcement at Cornwall Council to investigate
Cllr Greenwood- Penny Gave a report on the site visit with The Chairman of PPC and County Councillor Sherfield Wong 15 residents turned out to voice there disproval of the fences and restricted access to The Green, he was hopeful something positive would come out of it.
Cllr Jago. Raised the issue of non-attendance of the County Councillor Tara Sherfield Wong and that it should be noted.
Green Gym – Installation booked for 2nd August 2021 MUGA would follow at a later date
Status of PPC NDP – Stuart Todd has now reviewed and revised the Plan, reviewed Regulation 14 responses and dialogue with Steering Group ongoing. The next stage would be a meeting with him.
Surveyors Report ST Pirans Hall Cllrs. Griffiths and Sharp volunteered to be the Parish Council representatives to review the surveyors Report with the St Pirans Hall Committee
Correspondence, telephone calls and other reports:
Mr J Green NDP Response to Green Space
Cornwall Planning re NDP Green Space Response to be made by NDP steering Group
Mr & Mrs Wyatt have requested a meeting with the NDP Sterring Group re Green Space inclusion. Clerk to arrange.
Footpaths and Rights of Way
Date of next meeting – Monday 23rd August 2021 7pm to be held at St Piran’s Hall
Advance notice of items for agenda. Councillors to forward any items to the Clerk in advance of the meeting agenda being prepared but to include
• Perranuthnoe Car park & Toilets
• Co Option new Councillors
Financial & Confidential Matters:
The Meeting closed at 21.18